CBC Meets with FBI Director Over ‘Black Identity Extremists’ Report

Lexington Police Department “aware” of report; National Police Organization denounces classification

By Stacy M. Brown (NNPA Newswire) and Patrice Muhammad

Rep. Cedric Richmond (D-La.) will lead the Congressional Black Caucus (CBC) during the 115th Congress. Photo taken during a recent ceremonial swearing-in event for the 115th Congress in Washington, D.C. (Freddie Allen/AMG/NNPA)

FBI Director Christopher A. Wray failed to explain why the agency he leads changed the name of a domestic terrorism designation from “Black Separatist Extremist” to “Black Identity Extremist,” during a recent meeting with a group of Congressional Black Caucus (CBC) members about a leaked FBI document.

Wray also refused to acknowledge that Black activists, including Black Lives Matter organizers, are being monitored by the FBI, according to CBC members present at the meeting.

The leaked FBI document, titled “Black Identity Extremists Likely Motivated to Target Law Enforcement Officers,” sparked a wave of controversy and sharp criticism of the FBI.

The document was shared widely with local law enforcement agencies across the country, including Lexington Police Department.

In a statement requested for this article, Lexington Police Spokesperson Sgt. Jervis Middleton said, “We are aware of this report and have not implemented any policy changes that relate to this.”

At least one CBC member called the leaked document “COINTELPRO 2.0,” while another said that the report “calls for open season on Black activists.”

Lexington Police declined to respond to direct questions about whether they have a list of individuals or groups who have been labeled by the FBI or local Police as “Black Identity Extremists’’ or if there is monitoring of such.

“We train and prepare in many ways for various scenarios/incidents should they arise in our city, however we do not discuss our tactics,’’ Sgt. Middleton said.

Lexington Law Enforcement Veteran Lawrence Weathers said, “Everyone should have great concern with labeling and attaching negative and/ or criminal connotations to those who are legitimately expressing their opinions. Law Enforcement should not focus solely upon the group or group(s) someone is affiliated with, but should always concentrate on any suspected criminal nexus or criminal involvement and not cast a broad net to include all members of a group simply because of the actions, comments, and claims of a few individuals who commit criminal acts.”

Weathers was assistant chief for the Bureau of Special Operations for the Lexington-Fayette County Division of Police and is now Director of Law Enforcement Fayette County Public Schools.

Additionally, in 2014 Weathers was among the four finalists for Lexington Chief of Police and is now the President of the local chapter of NOBLE (National Organization of Black Law Enforcement Executives).

NOBLE National President Clarence E. Cox III


National NOBLE President Clarence E. Cox III, issued a statement on behalf of the membership. “It is our sincere belief that this type of report and classification further distances communities of color from the law enforcement community. Secondly, this assessment resurrects the historically negative legacy of African American civil rights leaders who were unconstitutionally targeted and attacked by federal, state, and local law enforcement agencies for seeking full U.S. citizenship under the law.”

The FBI documents were released, because of a lawsuit to expose the surveillance filed by the Center for Constitutional Rights and the civil rights group Color of Change.

On Wednesday, November 29, Congressional Black Caucus Chair Cedric Richmond (D-La.) and 2nd Vice Chair Karen Bass (D-Calif.), provided an overview of their meeting with Wray in a teleconference with National Newspaper Publishers Association (NNPA) President Dr. Benjamin F. Chavis; NNPA National Chairman Dorothy Leavell; and a group of Black publishers, editors and reporters.

“Listening to [Wray], especially considering meetings and discussions we’ve had with Attorney General [Jeff] Sessions, he appeared to be a breath of fresh air,” Bass said.

According to Bass, Wray said the “Black Identity Extremists” report was completed prior to his taking the post, but he acknowledged that he “owns the document” now.

Wray also said that no one would be investigated or targeted, unless they met three points of criteria: there had to be credible evidence of federal crimes; a credible threat of force or violence; and both of those points had to exist in furtherance of a social or political goal.

Bass said the FBI uses that criteria to categorize people as domestic terrorists and, according to the leaked document, “Black Identity Extremists” fall into the category of domestic terrorism.

Wray also admitted that the policy wasn’t new, the name simply changed, Bass said.

“They used to call it ‘Black Separatist Extremists’ and they changed it to ‘Black Identity Extremists,’” said Bass. “[Wray] didn’t have a lot of rationale for why that change took place, except for the fact that the people that fall under the category ‘Black Identity Extremist’ don’t seem to be separatists in today’s world.”

CBC members raised major concerns about the report, one of which was how FBI even crafted the methodology to come up with the category of “Black Identity Extremists.”

“[Wray] essentially said that they used ‘open source’ documents, which means news reports,” said Bass. “Lord knows what that means.”

Bass said that, based on what she heard from Wray, the methodology seemed “flimsy.”

“When we raised our concerns that a new generation of Black activists were being targeted [including the Black Lives Matter movement] for surveillance and harassment, [Wray] said repeatedly that there was no investigation of the Black Lives Matter movement,” said Bass.

Bass and the other CBC members let Wray know that they were “completely aware” that some activists in their communities were experiencing surveillance and harassment, even though they didn’t meet the requirements that Wray described that would lead to an investigation.

The CBC members asked the FBI to retract the document and issue a new message to local law enforcement agencies.

“One of the problems with this document is that it has been widely distributed to law enforcement agencies around the country,” said Bass. “Many of us referenced either our own personal experiences or experiences we were aware of during the ‘COINTELPRO’ years. when if you send a document like this out to local law enforcement, in many of our opinions, you can declare open season on Black activists, because, then local law enforcement agencies can use the document as justification for doing whatever they want to do.”

The Counter Intelligence Program

COINTELPRO, or the “Counter Intelligence Program” of the FBI, was designed in part to “expose, disrupt, misdirect, discredit, or otherwise neutralize the activities of the Black nationalists,” during the 1950s and 1970s.

Writing for the Huffington Post, G. Flint Taylor, a founding partner of the People’s Law Office in Chicago, said that hundreds of documents were uncovered during a court case in 1976 that revealed that the FBI also plotted to destroy a children’s breakfast program run by the Black Panther Party and “disrupt distribution of the BPP newspaper.”

The documents exposed in the 1976 court case also revealed, “massive wiretap overhears, including conversations between BPP members and their attorneys,” Taylor wrote.

“The FBI denies they are surveilling (sic) our groups like the Black Lives Matter movement, but we told them that we don’t believe it and our information tells us that those groups are under surveillance,” said Richmond.

Richmond said that the CBC members plan to present information to the FBI detailing surveillance and harassment of Black organizers.

The FBI director expressed interests in meeting with CBC members regularly because, “We are the eyes and ears on the ground,” and the CBC offers diversity that the agency lacks, said Richmond.

Bass asked the Black Press to put the call out to their readers to let lawmakers know if they have experienced harassment or surveillance, a request that Richmond echoed.

Chavis, the president and CEO of the NNPA, committed to working with Richmond and other CBC members to uncover stories of unwarranted government surveillance and harassment in the Black community.

Lexington NOBLE Chair Weathers said, “As the saying goes, if we forget history, we are doomed to repeat it.  NOBLE is taking a vocal stand to help ensure this history is never repeated.”

Redacted FBI report.BIE-Redacted